28 U.S.C. 1367: Supplemental Claims and Remand

28 U.S.C. § 1367 can allow a federal court to hear related claims beyond those supporting original jurisdiction. The claims must satisfy the statutory same-case-or-controversy requirement, and additional restrictions and discretionary grounds can apply. Supplemental jurisdiction is not an independent reason every state-law dispute belongs in federal court. [1]

Start with an actual original-jurisdiction claim

Identify the federal-question, diversity, or other basis that brings the case within federal original jurisdiction. Then explain the factual relationship between that claim and the proposed supplemental claims. Sharing a party or a broad subject is not necessarily enough. Section 1367 refers to the same constitutional case or controversy. [1]

Removal from state court has separate statutory requirements. A defendant should not assume that describing a claim as supplemental creates removability when no proper original-jurisdiction basis exists. Read the removal statute along with the complaint and procedural history. [2]

Diversity cases have specified restrictions

Where original jurisdiction is founded solely on diversity, subsection (b) limits specified claims involving parties joined under particular civil rules when exercising jurisdiction would be inconsistent with Section 1332. The exact party, claim, joinder rule, and citizenship issue matter. Do not simplify the provision into either unlimited joinder or a ban on every additional state claim. [1]

Section 1367 also allows a court to decline jurisdiction in listed circumstances, including complex state-law issues, substantial predominance, dismissal of all original-jurisdiction claims, or other exceptional compelling reasons. That is a statutory analysis, not an automatic result whenever one federal claim disappears.

Dismissal, remand, and limitation periods differ

If the court declines a supplemental claim, determine what order was entered and where the claim can proceed next. A removed case can raise remand issues different from dismissal of a case originally filed in federal court. Avoid assuming the same procedural result applies in both settings. [1] [2]

The statute also provides a limitations-tolling rule for covered claims while pending and for the specified period after dismissal, unless state law provides longer protection. It should not be treated as a universal thirty-day deadline without calculating the actual claim’s remaining time and applicable law. Preserve the federal orders, claim dates, and state limitation analysis before deciding when or how to refile. [1]

Related questions

See 28 U.S.C. 1332: Diversity Jurisdiction and federal-question jurisdiction.

Primary sources

  1. 28 U.S.C. § 1367 — Office of Law Revision Counsel
  2. 28 U.S.C. § 1441 — Office of Law Revision Counsel

Sources checked: October 31, 2026.